Quick answer: A used engine usually costs the least but has an unknown history and a short warranty, if any. A remanufactured engine is rebuilt to factory specifications with new wear parts; AutoZone and Kelley Blue Book say it can be as reliable as a new engine for less money. A new engine costs the most. The right choice depends on your budget, how long you’ll keep the vehicle and the warranty you want.
What is a used engine?
A used engine comes out of a salvage vehicle and usually gets little or no reconditioning. JASPER Engines, a remanufacturer, notes that its history, including maintenance and driving conditions, is often unknown, and any wear it already has stays with it.
Watch out for: unknown history.
Warranty: often short, around 30 to 90 days, or none, according to JASPER.
What is a remanufactured engine?
Kelley Blue Book says remanufactured engines are overhauled in a factory setting, machined to original tolerances, and parts that wear, like crankshaft bearings, piston rings and seals, are replaced.
Reliability: AutoZone says it’s typically just as reliable as a new engine and costs less. Done correctly, Kelley Blue Book says it can last well beyond 100,000 miles.
Warranty: many come with warranties covering multiple years and unlimited miles.
Cost: about $5,000 to $9,000 for a mainstream vehicle, plus labor, according to Kelley Blue Book.
What is a new or crate engine?
A new engine has never been run before. AutoZone says it’s the most expensive option. Kelley Blue Book cites Cox Automotive data putting the average dealership price close to $8,000, and high-output engines can cost three or four times that. Availability isn’t guaranteed for older models.
Which engine is right for my vehicle?
Kelley Blue Book says the choice should depend on your budget, how long you want to keep the vehicle and your warranty needs. Also consider the condition of the rest of the vehicle. Not sure whether to fix it at all? Read Should I replace my engine or buy another car?
Do you replace diesel engines?
No. We work on gasoline engines only, including trucks and SUVs like the F-150, Silverado and Ram, and imports like Toyota, Honda, Nissan, Hyundai and Kia.
Need help with your vehicle in Port Richey?
Twin Brothers Automotive is a family-owned shop at 6105 Sherwin Drive in Port Richey, FL, with an ASE Master Certified technician, digital vehicle inspections and a 12-month / 15,000-mile warranty. We have 200+ five-star Google reviews. Book online or call (727) 645-5092.
Frequently asked questions
For many drivers, yes. A remanufactured engine has its wear parts replaced and is machined to factory specifications, and many come with multi-year warranties. A used engine has an unknown history and usually a short warranty, if any.
AutoZone says a remanufactured engine is typically just as reliable as a new engine, and Kelley Blue Book says one done correctly should be as good as new.
There is no single cutoff. Because a used engine’s history is often unknown, ask for its mileage and where it came from before you approve it. We share that information with every used-engine quote.
Sources
- Kelley Blue Book, “Should I Get a Rebuilt or Remanufactured Engine?” kbb.com
- AutoZone, “Engine Replacement Cost.” autozone.com
- JASPER Engines & Transmissions, “Check Engine Light On? Here’s How to Choose the Right Replacement” (a remanufacturer’s guide). jasperengines.com
Sources checked October 2026. Prices are national estimates from the sources above and are not a quote.
